I have tried the reduced fat stuff in the past, but they add so much sugar and artificial sweetener to it that I honestly feel like the whole fat stuff is actually healthier for you!

This is absolutely true. your statement reminded me of a fad in the late 90's where there was a craze to have low-fat or no-fat alternatives to everything and everyone was reading labels ONLY for the fat content. I fell victim to this as well and we are all idiots I guess because in lieu of fat, they were throwing a ton of sweeteners in there that as it turns out is much worse for you than fat is!