Sort:  

I would say yes. However, honest work within the laws that are in force in the country.

Legality is no basis for morality. In 1850, slavery was legal, slave patrols were "law enforcement," and escaped slaves were "guilty" of stealing themselves. The Underground Railroad was a conspiracy to break federal law. No, real crime requires violating someone else's rights.

Legality is no basis for morality. - Hands down for this sentence.

Yes, but if the only crime you commit is to not be there legally its fine by me

Here, we have a problem. For me, the law is the law (and it should be that way anywhere in the world).

The law is the law but i believe sometime it is fair to not follow the law, if your getting attacked you have to attack back even if its unlawfull, if you are living in a country in war and almost die for your own safety you have to act unlawfull.

Law is to be followed most of the time, but in some specific situations law can be not correct.

Modern economy need poorer worker to grow these illegal imigrants are perfect for this too

getting attacked you have to attack back

Self-defense.

almost die for your own safety you have to act unlawfull.

No


Why not just make those illegal imigrants legal then and then pay them a fair wage? Ohh, because the CEO's don't care about people, only getting more money.

"Self-defense" can bring you in a lot of judicaire trouble around europa.

Why not make them legals ? Well i would, i would but i'm not the one in charge. (I would legalize any good working, honest anf fairly integrated individual)

Not sure what you mean.
I live in Europe aswell xD

It mean that if you do self defense in most of europe countries you act unlawfully

I kinda agree with you on this, except here: sometimes is it fair not to follow the law, because in this case, the law must be 100% respected.

Yes but you got the point, its better to act unlawfull temporaly than to die.

For sure.

Sadly, no one seem to have convinced you

Its not honest work if its illegal? xD

I make a difference betwhen a drug dealer -> illegal because of the action, and an illegal that work innthe fields -> illegal by satus, in the second case seems like honest work yes

Vices are not crimes. Arguing something is "illegal" has no moral or rational basis in and of itself.

It has, places have set of rules called laws if you enter these places you agree to respect them

No, I cannot consent to the arbitrary dictates of a political class just by existing or traveling. I respect the rights of individuals, but not the claims to authority made by governments.

I mean of its a democraty it mean thats the way the people living there decided that the land ahould be, so in a way gov is a mix of indiviual.

Might not be perfect, but what better syteme do you imagine ?

Democracy is government by bandwagon fallacy and false choice, plus the problem of politicians lying to get elected, and then using the proceeds of political plunder to buy more power. Representation is a myth. It's not perfect, but it's even a good system.

Legality has no inherent moral or rational authority.

I dont care about your guys opinion xD

Unlike people who declare things "legal" and "illegal," I won't threaten to rob you, lock you in a cage, or shoot you for just living life as a peaceable person who chooses to do things I personally dislike. Just don't violate someone else's life, liberty, or property.

Dont be illegal then?
I don't care what USA do with those people.

Here is the thing. I am not an Amercian Citzen, sooooo my opinion also doesn't mean anything xD

But I fucking love the closed border policy!

You're free to have an opinion. geography doe snot confer expertise by default. However, an informed and reasoned opinion on any topic is always better than one based on political BS.

Someone made a list of the "Danish Immigrant Model" and its gaining traction in EU ;)
P.s. I am Danish and I am all for it.

Skærmbillede 2025-08-06 191132.png